Photo courtesy of Catelli’s
Small town, big appetite. Geyserville might fly under the radar compared to Healdsburg, but locals know it’s home to some of Sonoma’s most character-driven dining. From Michelin-star artistry to classic Italian family recipes, here’s where to eat (and what to order) when you’re exploring Wine Country along Highway 128.
At Francis Ford Coppola Winery’s on-site restaurant, the menu reads like a love letter to Italian home cooking—think wood-fired pizzas, slow-braised short ribs, and fresh pastas paired with estate wines. The terrace views stretch across Alexander Valley, and the scene buzzes with both tourists and locals.
Favorite Local’s Dish: The Coppola Family Meatballs or Pasta Sofia—longtime staples that regulars come back for again and again.
Tip: Grab a sunset reservation on the terrace and linger for a post-dinner cocktail in the movie-themed gallery.
Visit: 300 Via Archimedes, Geyserville, CA 95441
Contact: (707) 857-1471
Price Range: $$$
Website: francisfordcoppolawinery.com/dine-at-the-winery
Cyrus returned to Sonoma with a new Geyserville location and quickly earned a Michelin star for its reimagined tasting-menu journey—an experience that blends art, storytelling, and serious culinary precision. Expect multiple courses, creative plating, and service that’s polished but never stiff.
Favorite Local’s Dish: The Dining Journey Menu—it changes often, but locals rave about the caviar service and wagyu course.
Tip: Book early and plan for a three-hour experience; this is a true dining event, not a quick bite.
Visit: 275 CA-128, Geyserville, CA 95441
Contact: (707) 723-5999
Price Range: $$$$
Website: cyrusrestaurant.com
This Geyserville mainstay blends rustic Italian charm with serious culinary chops. Everything’s made in-house at Diavola—from the dough to the cured meats—and the wood-fired oven rarely cools.
Favorite Local’s Dish: The Bee Sting, topped with spicy salami, Fior di Latte, and local honey, is the go-to order for regulars.
Tip: Locals head next door to the Geyserville Gun Club for a cocktail while waiting for a table—a perfect pairing.
Visit: 21021 Geyserville Avenue, Geyserville, CA 95441
Contact: (707) 814-0111
Price Range: $$
Website: diavolapizzeria.com
Equal parts speakeasy and locals’ hangout, the Geyserville Gun Club serves craft cocktails, tacos, and late-night bites with plenty of personality. It’s where chefs and winemakers go to unwind.
Favorite Local’s Dish: Korean Tacos—crispy, rich, and the most-ordered plate in the house.
Tip: Go Thursday or Friday after dinner for live music or spontaneous DJ sets that keep the small-town night alive.
Visit: 21025 Geyserville Avenue, Geyserville, CA 95441
Contact: (707) 814-0036
Price Range: $$
Website: geyservillegunclub.com
A third-generation, family-run Italian restaurant known for fresh pasta, local wines, and a patio built for long lunches. Catelli’s keeps things simple and flavorful—handmade ravioli, meatballs, and seasonal specials.
Favorite Local’s Dish: The 10 Layer Lasagna—a signature family recipe that’s been on the menu for decades.
Tip: Split the Meatball Sliders as an appetizer; it’s the off-menu favorite everyone talks about.
Visit: 21047 Geyserville Avenue, Geyserville, CA 95441
Contact: (707) 857-3471
Price Range: $$–$$$
Website: mycatellis.com
From charming inns to luxurious resorts, Sonoma County has a bit of everything. Discover your perfect spot to call home for a few days in our guide to Sonoma’s best hotels.
Just ten minutes south, Healdsburg delivers a broader range of dining—from Michelin-star tasting menus to neighborhood favorites. Here are a few worth planning around:
Between Geyserville’s tight-knit food scene and Healdsburg’s broader mix of restaurants, this stretch of northern Sonoma is a diner’s dream. Whether you’re splitting pizza downtown, indulging in a Michelin-starred tasting menu, or sipping cocktails late at the Gun Club, every meal pairs perfectly with the region’s relaxed pace—and a good glass of wine.
